The Varsity Depth Chart Is Lying to You: How to Evaluate Your Roster Before Contact

Read the Article

The full text of “The Varsity Depth Chart Is Lying to You: How to Evaluate Your Roster Before Contact”, from the Vol 2 — Summer 2026 issue.

The Varsity D The Varsity D Is Lying Is Lying The Varsity Depth Chart Is Lying to You How to evaluate your roster before contact BY AFQ STAFF Every coach thinks he knows his team in July. He knows the returning starters and the seniors. He knows who had a good winter, which athletes look different in the weight room and which young players everyone is excited about. Then football starts, and some of those assumptions hold up. Others do not.

That is why the July depth chart can be dangerous—not because it is useless, since a staff needs a starting point, but because it can become too comfortable. The July depth chart is usually built on reputation, seniority, body type, attendance, potential and what coaches believe will happen once contact starts. Some of that matters. It is not the whole truth. Before contact

37 epth Chart epth Chart to You to You begins, coaches can still learn a lot about their roster. They just have to know what to look for. The best 11 in shorts are not always the best 11 on Friday night—but summer tells you more than you think. EVALUATE MOVEMENT, NOT JUST SIZE Summer can fool coaches. A player looks the part—size, strength, years in the program, fills out the uniform. But can he move? Football is not a still picture.

Evaluate change of direction, balance, body control, first-step quickness, the ability to bend and recover, the ability to play in space and conditioning through repeated movement. It matters at every position. A lineman who cannot

38 redirect will struggle against movement. A linebacker who looks strong but cannot open his hips will struggle in coverage. A receiver who tests fast but cannot get in and out of breaks will disappear, and a defensive back who looks smooth in drills but panics with the ball in the air is not ready. Movement tells the truth earlier than contact. Watch it closely. COMMUNICATION IS A DEPTH CHART TRAIT In July, communication may be the clearest sign of readiness. Who talks?

Who echoes calls and helps younger players line up? Who understands formations, recognizes motion, can explain the drill and corrects himself before a coach does? The player who communicates is usually processing the game. The silent player may still be learning—that does not mean he cannot play—but if the position requires communication, silence becomes a problem. Centers, quarterbacks, linebackers, safeties and special teams leaders have to talk.

If they do not talk in July, do not assume they will suddenly get loud in August. Silence in July does not turn into a voice in August. EFFORT UNDER FATIGUE TELLS THE STAFF WHO IS REAL Everybody looks good early in practice. The better question is what happens late. When players are tired, who still finishes? Who jogs to the back of the line, loses technique, stops communicating or gets emotional? Who brings energy to others, and who looks for shortcuts?

Fatigue exposes habits, and July can reveal Friday night behavior before Friday night arrives. A player who stops finishing when tired may become a fourth-quarter problem. A player who gets louder and more focused when tired may be ready for more responsibility. Evaluate conditioning periods, competitive circuits and late-practice team periods—not just for speed, for response. Fatigue does not create character. It reveals habits.

Coaches like Dabo Swinney increasingly embrace aggressive play-calling, reflecting a broader shift seen in both fourth-down decisions and point-after attempts. RETENTION MATTERS A player who learns fast has value. A player who needs the same correction every day slows the team down. July is a good time to evaluate retention because the staff is teaching constantly.

Track who remembers yesterday’s correction, who improves after film, who carries classroom work to the field, who understands concepts instead of memorizing words, who can explain the why and who repeats the same mistake. This matters most for younger players competing for varsity roles. The most athletic player is not always ready. The player who can learn, retain and apply coaching may be closer than people think.

COACHABILITY IS NOT PERSONALITY Some players are quiet and coachable. Some are emotional and coachable. Some say the right things and never change. Do not confuse personality with coachability. Coachability means the player improves after correction—that is it. When corrected, does he listen, ask a useful question, apply it on the next rep, skip the excuses and show improvement over time? A player does not have to be perfect. He has to be correctable, and July gives coaches dozens of chances to see whether he is.

The best summer players are not the ones who never make mistakes. They are the ones who fix them fastest. ALIGNMENT AND ASSIGNMENT BEFORE CONTACT Before full contact, players can still show whether they know where to be. Can they align correctly, handle shifts and motion, adjust to formations, understand spacing, fit conceptually in walkthroughs and play assignment football without constant help? This matters because contact will not fix confusion. It will magnify it.

A player who cannot align in July may not be ready for a major role in August, and a player who consistently knows where to be may deserve a harder look even if he is not the most impressive athlete. The depth chart has to value reliability. SPECIAL TEAMS MAY IDENTIFY YOUR REAL DEPTH Summer special teams work reveals players who are not yet starters but are ready to help the varsity. A backup linebacker who communicates, runs and tackles in space may be valuable on kickoff.

A young receiver who competes as a gunner may be closer than expected. A sophomore defensive back who handles return rules deserves attention, and a lineman who can protect on PAT may be more useful than the staff realized. Special teams are not just extra reps. They are evaluation reps, and they show courage, effort, awareness and trust. Sometimes your depth is hiding in special teams periods.

CREATE A JULY EVALUATION BOARD Instead of only listing starters and backups, build a summer evaluation board and grade players in the categories July can actually show you. The board does not replace the depth chart. It challenges it—and it keeps reputation from controlling every decision.

Category What you are grading Where it shows up in July Movement Change of direction, bend, recovery, play in space Agility and position drills, 7-on-7 Communication Echoes calls, gets others aligned, can explain the drill Walkthroughs, team periods, special teams Effort under fatigue Finishes late in practice; brings energy to others Conditioning, competitive circuits, last team period Retention Carries yesterday’s correction onto today’s field Film to field, day-to-day corrections Coachability Improves after correction without excuses Every individual period

Category What you are grading Where it shows up in July Alignment and assignment Knows where to be against shifts and motion Walkthroughs, install periods Special teams value Courage, awareness and effort without a headline Coverage, return and protection periods Leadership response What he does when it gets hard Adversity, lost reps, hot practices The July depth chart should be questioned before August makes the questions harder. FINAL THOUGHT The varsity depth chart is not lying on purpose.

It is simply incomplete—a reflection of what the staff believes before the hardest evidence arrives. But July gives coaches clues. Movement, communication, fatigue, retention, coachability and special teams all give clues, and the best staffs use them. Once contact begins, decisions come faster, roles harden, reps get more valuable and the wrong assumptions get more expensive. Evaluate honestly now. The roster may already be telling you the truth.

Do not wait for full pads to find out which players are already earning trust.